But Ben replies that they are on the list, and who are they to question who is on the list or not. Juliet then says that they have been asking about their mother in Los Angeles, and since they are only children, if they really belong on the Island with them. They start to talk about Zach and Emma and how good Juliet has been with them.
Ben tricked her into an evening alone with him. Three weeks after, Ben invites Juliet to a dinner party, which turns out to be a private date for just the two of them. Then Juliet and Harper exchange glaces, too. Goodwin leaves without looking at Harper. This time we see Juliet and Goodwin exchanging worried glances in front of Harper. Juliet expresses that she is still concerned Ben would be upset, but Goodwin laughs dismissively: what is he going to do? ♪ The scene immediately jumps to the previously shown scene of the barracks' perspective of the crash of Flight 815 including Ben telling Goodwin to go undercover. Goodwin says that he has been working with chemicals that could kill every man, woman, and child on the Island if he flips the wrong switch, and that Ben has enough on his plate than to worry about the two of them. Goodwin asks if it is because Ben has a crush on her, and reveals that everyone recognizes this fact because Ben "follows her around like a puppy". Goodwin says he wants to tell everyone about their relationship, and that it shouldn't matter to his wife (he has been sleeping on the couch for over a year), but Juliet says Ben wouldn't like it. Some time after, Goodwin and Juliet are on a private date at a beach far from the barracks. Juliet replies that she will not hurt him, but Harper says that she is not talking about Juliet, but about what Ben will do if he finds out, as Ben is smitten with Juliet because she "looks just like 'her.'" Harper reveals that she followed them and watched them having sex, and then adds that if she continues having an affair with Goodwin, there will be "consequences" and she doesn't want Goodwin to get hurt. Later that day, Harper confronts Juliet during a therapy session about the affair Juliet's been having with Goodwin and asks when they started sleeping together, something Juliet initially denies. Ben watches, seemingly now aware of a romantic relationship between the two of them. Seeing Ben, he becomes awkward and asks if either of them would like a sandwich left by Ethan. Juliet is discussing the problem with pregnancy on the Island with Ben when Goodwin barges into the lab, cheerfully calling to Juliet. Juliet says that if Goodwin promises not to tell his wife, she won't tell anyone he lied about his chemical burn. She makes snide comments about Harper, who turns out to be Goodwin's wife. Months later, Juliet is in her office weeping about the loss of a patient, Henrietta, when Goodwin enters and asks her to treat a burn he says he got from leaning against a transformer at a power station. When Juliet says it is unnecessary, as she'll only be there for six months, Ben responds that he wanted her to feel at home. Ben shows Juliet her welcoming gift: her own two-bedroom house, fully furnished with an opera music collection. They arrive at a house with Ben waiting on the porch. Tom talks about his own experience with Harper, saying she made him cry about his father.
They leave the therapist's office - a building in the barracks. Suddenly, Tom appears, and wants to take her to Ben. Harper, a therapist, arrives, and begins discussing with her why Juliet is the center of attention, and why that makes Juliet uncomfortable. Juliet is waiting in a nicely decorated room.